At Rigid Deck Company, we’re passionate about building outdoor spaces that stand the test of time, blending durability, style, and innovation. When it comes to composite decking, two brands often come up in the conversation: Deckorators and Trex. Both are industry leaders, but we’ve found that Deckorators consistently edges out Trex in key areas that matter most to our clients. Let’s dive into why Deckorators might be the superior choice for your next deck project, while also weighing the pros and cons of each to give you a clear picture.

Deckorators: Innovation Meets Longevity

Deckorators, a brand under Universal Forest Products, has redefined composite decking with its mineral-based composite (MBC) technology. Unlike Trex, which relies heavily on a wood-plastic composite blend, Deckorators’ MBC lines—like Voyage, Vault, and Frontier—replace organic wood fibers with a blend of minerals and polypropylene. This isn’t just a gimmick; it’s a game-changer. The result? Decks that are exceptionally strong, lightweight, and resistant to moisture, making them ideal for everything from backyard retreats to waterfront escapes.

The Pros of Deckorators Decking

1. Unmatched Durability: The mineral-based composite technology gives Deckorators an edge in strength and stability. It holds up to heavy loads—up to 1,075 pounds per 50 square feet in tests—outperforming Trex’s 872 pounds in similar conditions. This makes it a top pick for high-traffic areas or homes with heavy outdoor furniture.
2. Superior Moisture Resistance: Deckorators’ MBC decks are approved for ground and water contact, a claim Trex can’t make. This is a huge advantage for decks near pools, lakes, or in humid climates where moisture is a constant threat.
3. Minimal Thermal Expansion: Unlike wood-based composites, Deckorators’ MBC boards experience virtually no thermal expansion or contraction. This means tighter, more consistent gaps between boards, regardless of temperature swings—a practical benefit for both aesthetics and safety.
4. Enhanced Traction: The Voyage line, in particular, offers 34% more surface traction than many competitors, including Trex. This textured finish provides peace of mind for families with kids or pets, especially in wet conditions.
5. Generous Warranties: Deckorators backs its MBC lines with a 50-year structural warranty, plus a 25-year removal and replacement warranty that includes labor costs. Trex offers a solid 25-year warranty across the board, but it doesn’t cover labor or ground-contact damage, limiting its long-term value.

The Cons of Deckorators Decking

1. Higher Initial Cost: Deckorators’ advanced technology comes with a price tag. The MBC lines, while worth it for their longevity, can cost more upfront than Trex’s entry-level options like Enhance Basics.
2. Limited Color Options: While Deckorators offers stunning, modern hues, its color palette is narrower than Trex’s extensive range. If you’re after a highly specific shade, Trex might have more to offer.
3. Less Brand Recognition: Trex has been a household name since it pioneered composite decking in the ‘90s. Deckorators, though innovative, doesn’t yet have the same widespread familiarity, which can make some homeowners hesitant.

Trex: The Eco-Friendly Pioneer

Trex has earned its reputation as a leader in composite decking, and for good reason. Made from 95% recycled materials—think reclaimed wood and plastic film—it’s a darling of eco-conscious homeowners. Its high-performance shell technology, capping the boards on three sides, offers solid protection against fading, staining, and weathering. At Rigid Deck Company, we’ve installed plenty of Trex decks that still look great years later, especially in sunny, dry climates where moisture isn’t a major concern.

The Pros of Trex Decking

1. Eco-Friendly Credentials: Trex’s use of recycled materials resonates with clients who prioritize sustainability. It’s a feel-good choice that doesn’t sacrifice quality.
2. Wide Design Variety: With lines like Transcend, Select, and Enhance, Trex offers a dizzying array of colors and finishes. Whether you want a deep wood-grain look or a sleek, modern vibe, Trex has you covered.
3. Affordable Entry Points: The Enhance Basics line provides a budget-friendly option for those dipping their toes into composite decking, often undercutting Deckorators’ starting prices.
4. Low Maintenance: Like Deckorators, Trex requires minimal upkeep—just soap and water to keep it looking fresh. Its protective shell does a great job resisting stains and mold.

The Cons of Trex Decking

1. Moisture Vulnerability: Trex’s wood-based core can absorb water if the cap is scratched or if cut ends are exposed. This makes it less ideal for wet environments compared to Deckorators’ MBC.
2. Less Traction: Trex boards, while durable, don’t offer the same slip resistance as Deckorators’ Voyage line. In wet conditions, they can feel slicker underfoot.
3. Limited Warranty Scope: Trex’s 25-year warranty is solid but doesn’t cover labor or damage from ground contact. Deckorators’ broader coverage gives it an edge for long-term peace of mind.

Why Rigid Deck Company Leans Toward Deckorators

At Rigid Deck Company, we’re all about delivering decks that exceed expectations. While Trex is a fantastic option for many projects—especially those prioritizing eco-friendliness or a specific aesthetic—Deckorators often wins out for its cutting-edge technology and real-world performance. The mineral-based composite’s ability to shrug off moisture, resist thermal shifts, and handle heavy use aligns perfectly with our commitment to quality and durability.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between Deckorators and Trex depends on your priorities. If sustainability and a vast color selection are your top concerns, Trex might be your match. But if you’re after unmatched durability, moisture resistance, and a deck that’s built to last with minimal fuss, Deckorators is the way to go—and it’s why Rigid Deck Company proudly recommends it for projects that demand the best.

Ready to transform your outdoor space? Contact Rigid Deck Company today. We’ll walk you through your options, show you samples, and craft a deck that’s as unique and resilient as your home deserves.